Auditing & Accuracy
Verification Log
Sample claims across our guides checked against developer documentation and testing. This log tracks our test findings, remedied assumptions, and items currently undergoing confirmation.
Slack
Corrected
Claim
Public distribution does not require Marketplace review
Notes: The first AI draft said App Directory review was required. Slack's docs show Manage Distribution does not need it. Marketplace listing is separate.
Slack
Checked against docs
Claim
Bot scopes are fixed at install and new scopes need re-authorization
Notes: Read in Slack's docs.
Google
Corrected
Claim
Sensitive scopes need verification but not a security assessment
Notes: The first AI draft mixed sensitive and restricted scopes.
Google
Checked against docs
Claim
Restricted scopes need an assessment at least every 12 months
Notes: Read, not tested.
Google
Checked against docs
Claim
The demo video must be an Unlisted YouTube video showing the client ID
Notes: Read, not tested.
Google
Tested by me
Claim
Basic sign in scopes can be used with a test user before verification
Source
Notes: Tested on 31 Oct with basic scopes only. Sensitive and restricted scopes not tested.
Notion
Could not verify
Claim
Notion plans a mandatory review queue for public integrations
Source
Community forum
Notes: Rumor only. No official statement found.
| Guide | Claim | Status | Source | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slack | Public distribution does not require Marketplace review | Corrected | https://api.slack.com/start/distributing | The first AI draft said App Directory review was required. Slack's docs show Manage Distribution does not need it. Marketplace listing is separate. |
| Slack | Bot scopes are fixed at install and new scopes need re-authorization | Checked against docs | https://api.slack.com/authentication/oauth-v2 | Read in Slack's docs. |
| Sensitive scopes need verification but not a security assessment | Corrected | Google OAuth app verification docs | The first AI draft mixed sensitive and restricted scopes. | |
| Restricted scopes need an assessment at least every 12 months | Checked against docs | Google restricted scope verification docs | Read, not tested. | |
| The demo video must be an Unlisted YouTube video showing the client ID | Checked against docs | Google OAuth verification docs | Read, not tested. | |
| Basic sign in scopes can be used with a test user before verification | Tested by me | Google Cloud Console | Tested on 31 Oct with basic scopes only. Sensitive and restricted scopes not tested. | |
| Notion | Notion plans a mandatory review queue for public integrations | Could not verify | Community forum | Rumor only. No official statement found. |